Fresh & Delicious

Order Now

Fast & Easy Ordering

Order Now

Serving Erie & Niagara Since 2001

Order Now
1248 Ruie Rd, North Tonawanda, NY 14120 (716) 695-1592

Our Story

We are pizza & more! Satisfy your cravings with fresh meals from Good Guys Pizza! Our pizzeria and takeout restaurant features delicious options like salads, french fries & sandwiches. We use only the finest ingredients for your lunch or dinner and our pizzas come loaded with all your favorite toppings.

Since 2001 we have served gourmet selections to countless clients throughout Erie and Niagara Counties. We are open late to serve you and we accept phone & online orders. We are here for you. “You won't get a heartier, thicker, heavier, cheesier, greasier, saucier square of pizza than here up in North Tonawanda.”

Google Reviews

Ashley Oldman

We love good guys pizza. They are about the only place left that gives you a generous portion of everything you order. You don't have to order extra sauce or cheese and the pizza is fluffy and thick and also very consistent! It looks almost identical everytime we come!

SharkByte 360

Always our go to place for pizza. They are a little pricey, but oh so worth it. When you get wings, the BBQ is very saucy, and worth every penny. The cook on the pizza is always spot on, and two slices will fill you up. Very consistent.

Joseph Giambra

Probably the best pizza in NT, based on costs. They’re not cheap, but you’re getting WAY more for your money than you’ll ever get at Franco’s. I’m happy to pay extra for quality, and plenty of left overs.

Greg Estep

As a person whose favorite food is pizza, I have tried a lot of pizza over the years. Buffalo has the best pizza anywhere in North America IMO. I live in Northwest Ontario where the fishing is world class but the pizza is subpar to say the least.

Rosie Swartz

My favorite pizza place of all time! The french fries are also some of the best around(if you’re a french fry fanatic you know what I mean)! The NY style pizza is awesome as well. All around great choices can’t go wrong! My go to place for sure.

Bridget B

This place is freaking AMAZING!! HUGE portions with excellent food. It's a very small place with take out only. No dine in!! I was in the Buffalo area visiting a friend and got the loaded fries and a small steak sub. The fries were a meal alone.